See the description here.

Illinois has better top of the line wins, but also has worse losses and more of them.

Wins

Illinois (18 wins)Virginia Tech (23 wins)
ScoreOpponentAvgAvgOpponentScore
5854Wisconsin (24)N2432AGeorgia Tech (32)8882
6356Wisconsin (24)A2433HClemson (34)7059
7968Vanderbilt (25)H2434HWake Forest (36)8783
7873Michigan St. (29)H2641NSeton Hall (61)10394
7674Clemson (34)A2750HNorth Carolina (88)7470
7864Wofford (72)H3558HMiami FL (95)8166
8983Northwestern (119)H4763HNorth Carolina St. (97)7159
5144Michigan (131)A5768ANorth Carolina St. (97)7252
8853Western Michigan (154)H6872HGeorgia (104)7462
7767Penn St. (193)A8177HBoston College (122)6362
5453Penn St. (193)H9181HVirginia (126)6155
8477Boise St. (205)H10085AVirginia (126)7671
5749Iowa (209)A10992ACampbell (183)7160
5942Iowa (209)H116100APenn St. (193)6664
6660Indiana (220)A123107AIowa (209)7064
7270Indiana (220)H129115NDelaware (235)7466
8061Northern Illinois (261)H137123HNC Greensboro (248)5946
9448Presbyterian (324)H147130HBrown (253)6955
  HCharleston Southern (280)7350
  HLongwood (281)8550
  HVirginia Military Inst (302)9873
  HMD Baltimore County (327)7134
  HNorth Carolina Central (342)7230

Losses

Illinois (14 losses)Virginia Tech (8 losses)
ScoreOpponentAvgAvgOpponentScore
5860Utah (152)N152122ABoston College (122)6080
6873Northwestern (119)A136109NMiami FL (95)6570
6872Bradley (106)N126104AMiami FL (95)7582
6770Georgia (104)N120100ANorth Carolina (88)6478
6062Minnesota (59)H10888AFlorida St. (41)5863
6881Missouri (46)N9877HMaryland (22)100104
8385Gonzaga (39)N8968NTemple (12)5061
6373Michigan St. (29)A8260ADuke (3)5567
5773Ohio St. (26)A  
5372Ohio St. (26)H  
8188Ohio St. (26)N  
5772Wisconsin (24)H  
6575Purdue (10)A  
7884Purdue (10)H