Each year around this time, it seems like there are too many at-large spots and too few quality teams to fill them. This year is no exception. I present to you: BubbleGrid.

1-251-501-1001-200RoadGood road winsBad home losses
TeamW-LWW+/-W+/-+/-+/-
Florida St.20-803-49265-5#32 Georgia Tech
#82 North Carolina
#100 Boston College
#109 North Carolina St.
Nevada Las Vegas21-72407359-3#7 New Mexico
#88 Arizona
#135 Utah
Marquette18-923-47045-5#44 Connecticut
#58 Cincinnati
#64 Seton Hall
#79 St. John's
#109 North Carolina St.
California20-900-45-1105-6#55 Arizona St.#145 UCLA
Virginia Tech21-702-27065-5
Florida20-923-37-165-4#53 Mississippi#213 South Alabama
UAB23-511-16299-3#59 Marshall
Texas El Paso22-50105167-2#35 UAB
#65 Memphis
#69 New Mexico St.
#74 Tulsa
Connecticut17-1233-58-232-6#9 Villanova
Dayton19-913-35-364-6
Old Dominion23-811-37038-6#14 Georgetown
#56 William & Mary
Rhode Island20-702-27198-5#41 Dayton
#92 Akron
#100 Boston College
Notre Dame19-1033-18132-6#14 Georgetown
#63 South Florida
#185 Loyola Marymount
St. Mary's23-502-15159-2#33 Utah St.
Washington18-92206162-6#108 Southern California
#156 Oregon
San Diego St.18-812-33-357-7
Wichita St.22-811-27385-7#83 Indiana St.
#85 Missouri St.
Mississippi St.21-801-36255-5#53 Mississippi
#96 South Carolina
#157 Rider
Siena24-600-45089-5#81 Iona
#94 Fairfield
Mississippi19-912-44-425-4#84 Georgia#139 Arkansas
Cornell22-400-21-2910-3#79 St. John's
Cincinnati16-1224-46-602-8#44 Connecticut
Illinois17-1134-25-316-3#18 Wisconsin
#27 Clemson

Shaded teams would be in as of today, as either an at-large berth or their conference's automatic qualifier. Green shaded values are good and red shaded values are bad, each based on historical selection trends.

Some observations:

  • St. Mary's and UTEP have roughly the same profile, so it will be interesting to see what other factors the committee considers. UTEP has more good road wins than St. Mary's, but St. Mary's worst loss is slightly better (#108 Southern Cal compared to #146 Houston) and the Gaels have a slightly better top-of-the-line profile (2-3 compared to 1-1 against RPI top 50). Neither has a signature win, but neither do a lot of bubble teams.

  • Off the bubble, it's a shame N.C. State couldn't win a few more RPI Top 100 games, or they'd be a legitimate bubble team. They have 4 wins over likely tournament teams, including two on the road and home over possible #1 seed Duke.