Disclaimer: I despise RPI as much as the next person, but for better or worse it's what the committee uses to organize opponents for comparison. My goal is to predict what the committee will do, so I reference it.

The #1 line

Other than that pesky loss column, Wichita State and Villanova have very similar profiles. Yet one is considered a #1 seed lock and the other may get knocked off the top line by the Big 10 champ (if it's Michigan) or the ACC champ (unlikely).

If Wichita State does end up on the top line, that would seem to indicate that the committee (as they usually say they do) pays little attention to power ratings (i.e., based on margin-of-victory) for top level seeding. I happen to think that any measure of "best teams" for selection and seeding should include power ratings, but the committee's guidelines are vague.

(By the way, it's OK to admire and respect the accomplishment of a 33-0 season and still not think that team is one of the four best teams in the land. Despite the strawman arguments otherwise.)

There seems to be consensus there isn't a lot of separation among the top 5-10 teams (partially because of the impact of injuries), so the distinction of a #1 seed may not mean much more than a bullet point in next year's media guide.

The cut line

As expected, Louisiana Tech fell out of the field after losing the CUSA championship game. The first two teams out (Southern Miss and Louisiana Tech) each have CTD model scores above 50%, meaning their profiles are historically at-large worthy. It just happens that enough other teams have profiles that are slightly more worthy.

Committee chairman Ron Wellman said on CBS this afternoon that injuries affect selection less than they affect seeding. That tells me that BYU is probably safe despite losing Kyle Collinsworth. Or that they weren't in the field in the first place.

SMU is closer to the cut line than many realize.

There seems to be a lot of Internet chatter arguing North Carolina State should sneak in. They may be closer to the line than the CTD model currently shows, but that 6-11 record against the top 100 likely won't offset having Syracuse as their only signature win.

I don't see Green Bay making it in the field either. They beat Virginia and played Wisconsin close (both at home), but have two home losses outside the top 100 (both to Milwaukee).

  • Hover over a value for more information
  • Shaded teams are predicted to be in the field
  • Teams with a * are the projected automatic qualifier (AQ) for their conference. Bold shaded teams have clinched the AQ berth
  • Teams are listed in order of their selection confidence by the CTD model. In other words, the last shaded non-AQ team is the last team in, and the first non-shaded team is the first team out.
1-251-501-1001-200RoadGood road winsBad home losses
TeamScoreW-LWW+/-W+/-+/-+/-
Memphis> 99.922-934-36-255-5#19 Louisville
BYU> 99.922-1113-38185-8#41 Stanford
#60 Saint Mary's
#71 San Francisco
Saint Joseph's> 99.923-92509187-4#43 Dayton
#94 La Salle
#95 St. Bonaventure
Oklahoma St.> 99.921-1215-68-333-7#88 West Virginia
Colorado> 99.923-1115-38-275-7#41 Stanford
Pittsburgh> 99.925-902-57-297-2#55 North Carolina St.
#79 Clemson
#83 Maryland
Dayton> 99.923-1024-210387-4#26 Saint Louis
#92 Mississippi
#95 St. Bonaventure
#176 USC
Arizona St.> 99.921-1114-38044-7#63 California#104 Washington
Stanford> 99.921-1225-47-336-5#23 Connecticut
#28 Oregon
#63 California
Providence *> 99.923-1122-38-276-6#77 St. John's
#77 St. John's
#132 Seton Hall
Tennessee> 99.920-1212-47-244-7#78 LSU#150 Texas A&M
Xavier> 99.921-1224-29064-6#77 St. John's#132 Seton Hall
Iowa99.320-1224-57-314-6#24 Ohio St.
#65 Illinois
Nebraska99.119-1234-36-333-8#21 Michigan St.
SMU96.123-934-14-256-6#23 Connecticut
Southern Miss74.125-601051810-5#34 North Dakota St.
#100 UTEP
Louisiana Tech67.526-71205-179-5#25 Oklahoma
Arkansas11.921-1123-29133-6#16 Kentucky
Missouri9.322-1112-27-263-7#55 North Carolina St.
#76 Arkansas
Florida St.2.619-1323-66-6-26-6#39 Pittsburgh
#79 Clemson
#110 Miami FL
Georgetown1.317-1435-17-322-8#132 Seton Hall
Minnesota1.119-1322-65-613-7#74 Richmond#125 Northwestern
Harvard *< 0.125-400-220811-3#84 Boston University#145 Yale
Green Bay< 0.121-611-14159-2#90 Cleveland St.#130 Milwaukee
#130 Milwaukee
North Dakota St. *< 0.122-600-22-1710-5#67 Western Michigan
California< 0.119-1314-65-615-6#28 Oregon
#41 Stanford
North Carolina St.< 0.121-1313-66-516-6#39 Pittsburgh
#42 Tennessee
#110 Miami FL
Illinois< 0.119-1414-55-5-16-7#21 Michigan St.
#48 Minnesota
#64 Iowa
#143 Purdue
Stephen F. Austin *< 0.129-200-10-11014-2
St. John's< 0.120-1212-56-424-5#40 Providence
#89 Marquette
Saint Mary's< 0.121-1101-45-186-5#82 Boise St.#206 Santa Clara
Utah< 0.119-1114-45-412-8#63 California
Toledo< 0.126-600-17299-5#91 Akron
Manhattan *< 0.125-700-164812-4#94 La Salle
#98 Canisius
#103 Quinnipiac
#226 Fordham
Georgia< 0.119-1302-57-1-14-7#49 Missouri
#78 LSU
#120 Vanderbilt
#157 Georgia Tech